Friday, October 22, 2010

Something Better Late Than Never

A Good Ad





When this spot first aired about a year ago, I remember being highly impressed. It presents a story in an entertaining way (love the animation) while still remaining very informative, both scientifically and as far as the consumer is concerned: scientifically, we are informed by the fact that Michelin's Energy Saver A/S tires can save up to 109 gallons of fuel over the life of the tires. What the consumer really cares about, though, is finding a solution to their problem. The problem in this case is this "enemy" of sorts (high gas prices), being personified by a literal gas pump monster. Then comes in the Michelin man, showing us that the answer to the big problem in everyone's minds is the use of the product--these particular tires. Managing to tell a good story in an entertaining way while being informative and persuasive makes this ad a "good" ad. Or, at the very least, good enough for this blog.

A Bad Ad


























Flipping through a Car & Driver a while back led to the discovery of what I knew instantly would be a perfect "bad" ad. It's hard to tell, but the full page spread displays a series of bottles strikingly similar to that of Cazadores tequila, except with various completely random logos on the front: A Mexican wrestler, a unicorn, a sandwich, and a fax machine. Finally, on the far right, a bottle with a stag or deer is shown, obviously separate from the rest (physically and in purpose). On the bottom right, in pretty small print, it says "Cazadores. The one with the deer on it."

Perhaps this just isn't my kind of humor, but I find the approach bland and dumb. In my opinion--aside from the sandwich and fax machine--the other bottles aren't all that far-fetched, at least not to the point that I'll remember Cazadores is "the one with the deer". I'm no expert, but from here the copy comes across as unintelligent and lazy. And while I'm sure similar sizes have been used successfully in the past, the font of the tagline is far too small to really grab my attention. Had I not been purposefully looking for ads for my adfile, I'm certain I would have missed it.

A Brand Ad






























A Public Service Ad








No comments:

Post a Comment