When this spot first aired about a year ago, I remember being highly impressed. It presents a story in an entertaining way (love the animation) while still remaining very informative, both scientifically and as far as the consumer is concerned: scientifically, we are informed by the fact that Michelin's Energy Saver A/S tires can save up to 109 gallons of fuel over the life of the tires. What the consumer really cares about, though, is finding a solution to their problem. The problem in this case is this "enemy" of sorts (high gas prices), being personified by a literal gas pump monster. Then comes in the Michelin man, showing us that the answer to the big problem in everyone's minds is the use of the product--these particular tires. Managing to tell a good story in an entertaining way while being informative and persuasive makes this ad a "good" ad. Or, at the very least, good enough for this blog.
A Bad Ad
Flipping through a Car & Driver a while back led to the discovery of what I knew instantly would be a perfect "bad" ad. It's hard to tell, but the full page spread displays a series of bottles strikingly similar to that of Cazadores tequila, except with various completely random logos on the front: A Mexican wrestler, a unicorn, a sandwich, and a fax machine. Finally, on the far right, a bottle with a stag or deer is shown, obviously separate from the rest (physically and in purpose). On the bottom right, in pretty small print, it says "Cazadores. The one with the deer on it."
Perhaps this just isn't my kind of humor, but I find the approach bland and dumb. In my opinion--aside from the sandwich and fax machine--the other bottles aren't all that far-fetched, at least not to the point that I'll remember Cazadores is "the one with the deer". I'm no expert, but from here the copy comes across as unintelligent and lazy. And while I'm sure similar sizes have been used successfully in the past, the font of the tagline is far too small to really grab my attention. Had I not been purposefully looking for ads for my adfile, I'm certain I would have missed it.
So I recently acquired a DSLR (Team Canon, naturally). This is perfect for Provo since 85% of the population thinks they're professional models--odd, because if I was a model I certainly wouldn't be living in Utah Valley.
Basically, I'm going to try and use my camera to it's maximum potential...
...by taking pictures of hot chicks.
Wrote this down in my English class the other day:
The theme would be a retro (of course) shoot at the hotel (Marriot's TownPlace Suites where I work; you should see the decor to get a better idea of what I'm thinking). The modern, simple, squared off design of the TPS will be perfect. Over the past couple of years, there has been a fortunate inspiration of 60’s design ethic, leading to everything becoming much more streamlined, narrow, and clean. This explains the skinny jeans, the skinny ties, the re-emergence of the two-button wool suit, and even the military-inspired designs in jackets and coats. The style still favors the blouse-y look on women, but always over a pair of skinny jeans and often either flats (TOM’s, Sperry’s, etc.) or the gladiator sandals. Natural look in hair for women is also big, and in this shoot we would certainly make the most of this. Shooting in black and white (and color, too), I want snaps from a room on the fourth floor, preferably with a view of the mountains. I’m picturing a bed that is unmade that has clearly been played in, and a model with perfectly tousled hair. The idea isn’t necessarily that any kind of romantic activity has been happening, but that there is still a fierce, sexy, messy, unafraid feeling about the girl, even after just a typical night of sleep. Ideal time would be at sundown and early evening.
In order to capture the concept of clothes, we should get some shots of her either getting ready for the day or ready for bed at night. This would include putting on lipstick in the mirror and shoes at the foot of the bed, maybe brushing teeth, and maybe making breakfast. Or maybe just her taking a moment to be introspective before she goes out for the day where she won't have a chance to just sit and think. I’m picturing her holding a coffee mug in an oversized button-up and no pants, where all we can see are her legs poking up from underneath. Definitely need something with her laughing while holding the bottom of a corded phone in her free hand.
I've been fortunate enough to be treated to these little gems:
...over the last several years. There have easily been 10 or 11 iterations of similar commercials. This hardly matters since they're all the same. Overly happy, poorly acted families get together around a table at Olive Garden and awkwardly tell a half joke while the rest of the people at the table force out a horribly plastic laugh.
They're campy, stupid, and do nothing to accomplish what I'm assuming is an attempt to make me believe I can have a good time if I go there. When the people come across as fake, I'm not immersed in them or the idea behind the ad.
The thing is that while these are pretty terrible commercials, they're pretty impressive considering they're done by an 8 year old.
Simply stated, these are the two major reasons why the following ad is so effective for me:
It wouldn't surprise me at all, then, to find that other participating members of the target market (men [predominantly straight men], and those who love sports) would also connect quite easily to the spot. A vast majority of the viewers have likely experienced some kind of moderately serious relationship in the past, and (this is aired on ESPN, mind you) many of these have probably witnessed some kind of strain on their relationship because of their love of sports. It is an occurrence common enough to be parodied and referenced over and over again in various settings, since most will at least recognize this situation, even if they haven't personally lived it themselves. An example for the ladies would be an obsession with shoes.
Furthermore, another obvious characteristic of the target market is that it consists of and is aimed towards people who watch ESPN. Again, the commercial aired on the same network, so it is apparent that the station would like to appeal to those viewers already participating in ESPN programming. It is essentially a shout out to their own viewers, searching for a reaffirmation in the minds of the audience members that this is why they watch ESPN--for the love of sports. Even if that can get a little out of hand sometimes...
Finally, a small chunk of the target market might be on the opposite side of things: the girls who know all too well what it's like to be attached to one of these crazy-obsessed sports fans. Even if a disgruntled ex of one of these men is watching, there's a laugh for her at the end when it is revealed this man has no one left who tolerates his addiction other than man's best friend.
I said in an earlier post that I can't remember a particular moment that launched my interest in the world of advertising. This remains true, but thinking back, I realize that Nike--a company that continues to produce incredible ads and campaigns today--played a large part in this growing interest of mine.
More for my own purposes than anything else, I'm going on a trip down memory lane, sponsored by our friends at Nike (c)(TM)(R):
Still far and away one of my favorite commercials--videos, even--of all time, I remember seeing this back in the early 2000's and getting chills, a reaction that hasn't subsided. The message is spectacularly inspiring: the undisputed greatest of all time in one of the most visible sports in America tells us about all the moments where he's fallen short (MJ, failing!). Then he reveals it is these mistakes and shortcomings that has lead him to doing better the next time, pushing him to the pinnacle of greatness.
I remember seeing this spot during my second semester here at school. As with the Jordan commercial, the effects of this particular ad are timeless and still carry the same emotional weight now as the first time I saw it. What I love most about this ad is its ability to remain effective despite the absence of any dialogue or text (at least up until the very end). Nike advertising does this frequently, and exceptionally well, and this is without a doubt my favorite example of such. Similarly, it is important to note the role that cinematography plays in an ad (or film) where dialogue isn't there to drive the narrative. Without the incredible shots and a clear portrayal of specific concepts and events, we wouldn't receive the intended message, wouldn't notice or be affected by the ad, and it would be a failure. As it stands, however, we understand the theme at play: famous, multi-millionaire athletes have to wake up just like the rest of us and when we train and exercise, if we want to experience even a modicum of the athletic success they posses, we need to rise early, work hard, and--most importantly--wear Nike gear.
From a technical standpoint, there had to be a very thorough, specific storyboard and shot list created before going into production. That way, the director could know what kind of shots he needed beforehand, in order to give us the entire message in a way that was clear and effective. I would also imagine that, when working with high-paid athletes, promptness and brevity are important elements to incorporate into a shoot.
This ad continues to exemplify the points discussed previously. Another example of fabulous cinematography (reminds me of something we've come to expect from a Christopher Nolan film) with little to no text or dialogue. Going in reverse, the theme at the end is twofold: There are no Cinderellas (a term commonly used in college basketball to indicate a smaller, lesser-known team that upsets a favorite; think David and Goliath), and that these teams (and the viewer, by extension) have the potential to become legendary. Similar to the "Awake" promo above, we see shots of teams considered to be among these "Cinderellas" (high school players running routes late at night; the Appalachian Mountaineers team that upset Michigan that year in NCAA football; Current Georgetown Men's basketball coach John Thompson III watching film of his father's '85 Hoyas team being upset by an underdog Villanova squad; the Boise State football team practicing the now infamous Statue of Liberty play that sealed their victory in the 2007 Fiesta Bowl) mixed in with those of clear-cut successes (All-Star NBA point guard Chris Paul, the aforementioned John Thompson III with the perennial contenders at Georgetown, and Micheal Jordan during his days at UNC). All of this is set to the soundtrack of a clock tower bell striking 12 times. The concluding scene involves a shot of the clock hitting midnight, tying the Cinderella theme together.
I don't know that the rest of these require analysis, but just to drive the point home (and for those not fortunate enough to have seen these before), there are a few more spots that follow in step with the others, including the David Fincher-directed effort immediately below:
(Directed by Micheal Mann; "Heat", "Collateral", "Miami Vice")
Finally, a look into the newest campaign from Wieden+Kennedy simply called "Boom!", which I should mention I saw today at the gym. I couldn't help but smile at the genius behind them: